- See ISO 27002:2022 Control 5.3 for more information.
- See ISO 27001:2013 Annex A 6.1.2 for more information.
Understanding ISO 27001:2022 Annex A Control 5.3 – The Importance of Segregation of Duties
The purpose of ISO 27001:2022 Annex A 5.3 – segregation of duties in the form of functional separation is to establish a management framework that will be used to initiate and control the implementation and operation of information security within a company.
According to ISO 27001:2022 Annex A control 5.3, previously known as 6.1.2 in ISO 27001:2013, conflicting duties and conflicting areas of responsibility are separated.
An organisation should consider and implement appropriate segregation of duties as part of the risk evaluation and treatment process. While smaller organisations may have difficulty with this, the principle should be applied as much as possible and proper governance and controls put in place for information assets with a higher risk/higher value.
To reduce the likelihood of unauthorised or unintentional modification or misuse of the organisation’s assets, conflicting duties and areas of responsibility need to be segregated.
Conflicting Duties and Areas of Responsibilities Explained
Almost every organisation has a set of policies and procedures that govern its internal operations. These policies and procedures are supposed to be documented, but this is not always the case.
There exists a danger that employees will become confused about their areas of responsibility if the P&Ps are not transparent or well-communicated. This becomes even more problematic when employees have overlapping or conflicting areas of responsibility.
Occasionally, conflicts can arise when employees have responsibilities related to a particular task that are similar or differing. As a result, employees may do the same thing twice or perform different functions that cancel out the efforts of others. This wastes corporate resources and reduces productivity, adversely affecting the company’s bottom line and morale.
This problem can be avoided by ensuring that your organisation does not experience conflicting areas of responsibility and knowing why and what you can do to prevent them. For the most part, this means separating duties so that different people handle different organisational roles.
ISO 27001 made easy
An 81% Headstart from day one
We’ve done the hard work for you, giving you an 81% Headstart from the moment you log on. All you have to do is fill in the blanks.
What Is The Purpose of ISO 27001:2022 Annex A 5.3?
In ISO 27001, Control 5.3 Segregation of Duties aims to separate conflicting duties. This reduces the risk of fraud and error and bypasses information security controls.
Annex A Control 5.3 Explained
In accordance with ISO 27001, Annex A Control 5.3 describes the implementation guidelines for segregating organisational tasks and duties.
By delegating sub-tasks to different individuals, this principle creates a system of checks and balances that can reduce the likelihood of errors and fraud occurring.
The control is designed to prevent a single person from being able to commit, conceal, and justify improper actions, thereby reducing the risk of fraud and error. It also prevents a single person from overriding information security controls.
In cases where one employee has all the rights required for the task, fraud and errors are more likely to occur. This is because one person can perform everything without any checks and balances. There is, however, a reduced risk of significant harm or financial loss from an employee when no single person has all the access rights required for a particular task.
What’s Involved and Requirements of Annex A 5.3
In the absence of proper separation of duties and responsibilities, fraud, misuse, unauthorised access, and other security issues may arise.
Additionally, segregation of duties is required to mitigate the risks of collaboration between individuals. These risks are increased when insufficient controls prevent or detect collusion.
As part of ISO 27001:2022, the organisation should determine which duties and responsibilities need to be separated and implement actionable separation controls.
Whenever such controls are not possible, particularly for small organisations with a limited number of employees, activity monitoring, audit trails, and management supervision can be used. Using automated tools, larger organisations can identify and segregate roles to prevent conflicting roles from being assigned.
Free yourself from a mountain of spreadsheets
Embed, expand and scale your compliance, without the mess. IO gives you the resilience and confidence to grow securely.
What Are the Changes and Differences From ISO 27001:2013?
ISO 27001:2022’s Annex A control 5.3 Segregation of Duties is a revised version of ISO 27001:2013’s Annex A control 6.1.2 Segregation of Duties.
Annex A 5.3 ISO 27001:2022 and Annex A 6.1.2 ISO 27001:2013 describe the same basic characteristics of the control “Segregation of duties”. However, the most recent version defines a number of activities that require segregation during implementation.
Among these activities are:
a) initiating, approving and executing a change;
b) requesting, approving and implementing access rights;
c) designing, implementing and reviewing code;
d) developing software and administering production systems;
e) using and administering applications;
f) using applications and administering databases;
g) designing, auditing and assuring information security controls.
Table of All ISO 27001:2022 Annex A Controls
In the table below you’ll find more information on each individual ISO 27001:2022 Annex A Control.
| Annex A Control Type | ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A Identifier | ISO/IEC 27001:2013 Annex A Identifier | Annex A Name |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.1 |
Annex A 5.1.1 Annex A 5.1.2 |
Policies for Information Security |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.2 | Annex A 6.1.1 | Information Security Roles and Responsibilities |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.3 | Annex A 6.1.2 | Segregation of Duties |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.4 | Annex A 7.2.1 | Management Responsibilities |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.5 | Annex A 6.1.3 | Contact With Authorities |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.6 | Annex A 6.1.4 | Contact With Special Interest Groups |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.7 | NEW | Threat Intelligence |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.8 |
Annex A 6.1.5 Annex A 14.1.1 |
Information Security in Project Management |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.9 |
Annex A 8.1.1 Annex A 8.1.2 |
Inventory of Information and Other Associated Assets |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.10 |
Annex A 8.1.3 Annex A 8.2.3 |
Acceptable Use of Information and Other Associated Assets |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.11 | Annex A 8.1.4 | Return of Assets |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.12 | Annex A 8.2.1 | Classification of Information |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.13 | Annex A 8.2.2 | Labelling of Information |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.14 |
Annex A 13.2.1 Annex A 13.2.2 Annex A 13.2.3 |
Information Transfer |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.15 |
Annex A 9.1.1 Annex A 9.1.2 |
Access Control |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.16 | Annex A 9.2.1 | Identity Management |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.17 |
Annex A 9.2.4 Annex A 9.3.1 Annex A 9.4.3 |
Authentication Information |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.18 |
Annex A 9.2.2 Annex A 9.2.5 Annex A 9.2.6 |
Access Rights |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.19 | Annex A 15.1.1 | Information Security in Supplier Relationships |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.20 | Annex A 15.1.2 | Addressing Information Security Within Supplier Agreements |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.21 | Annex A 15.1.3 | Managing Information Security in the ICT Supply Chain |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.22 |
Annex A 15.2.1 Annex A 15.2.2 |
Monitoring, Review and Change Management of Supplier Services |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.23 | NEW | Information Security for Use of Cloud Services |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.24 | Annex A 16.1.1 | Information Security Incident Management Planning and Preparation |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.25 | Annex A 16.1.4 | Assessment and Decision on Information Security Events |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.26 | Annex A 16.1.5 | Response to Information Security Incidents |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.27 | Annex A 16.1.6 | Learning From Information Security Incidents |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.28 | Annex A 16.1.7 | Collection of Evidence |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.29 |
Annex A 17.1.1 Annex A 17.1.2 Annex A 17.1.3 |
Information Security During Disruption |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.30 | NEW | ICT Readiness for Business Continuity |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.31 |
Annex A 18.1.1 Annex A 18.1.5 |
Legal, Statutory, Regulatory and Contractual Requirements |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.32 | Annex A 18.1.2 | Intellectual Property Rights |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.33 | Annex A 18.1.3 | Protection of Records |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.34 | Annex A 18.1.4 | Privacy and Protection of PII |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.35 | Annex A 18.2.1 | Independent Review of Information Security |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.36 |
Annex A 18.2.2 Annex A 18.2.3 |
Compliance With Policies, Rules and Standards for Information Security |
| Organisational Controls | Annex A 5.37 | Annex A 12.1.1 | Documented Operating Procedures |
| Annex A Control Type | ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A Identifier | ISO/IEC 27001:2013 Annex A Identifier | Annex A Name |
|---|---|---|---|
| People Controls | Annex A 6.1 | Annex A 7.1.1 | Screening |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.2 | Annex A 7.1.2 | Terms and Conditions of Employment |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.3 | Annex A 7.2.2 | Information Security Awareness, Education and Training |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.4 | Annex A 7.2.3 | Disciplinary Process |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.5 | Annex A 7.3.1 | Responsibilities After Termination or Change of Employment |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.6 | Annex A 13.2.4 | Confidentiality or Non-Disclosure Agreements |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.7 | Annex A 6.2.2 | Remote Working |
| People Controls | Annex A 6.8 |
Annex A 16.1.2 Annex A 16.1.3 |
Information Security Event Reporting |
| Annex A Control Type | ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A Identifier | ISO/IEC 27001:2013 Annex A Identifier | Annex A Name |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.1 | Annex A 11.1.1 | Physical Security Perimeters |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.2 |
Annex A 11.1.2 Annex A 11.1.6 |
Physical Entry |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.3 | Annex A 11.1.3 | Securing Offices, Rooms and Facilities |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.4 | NEW | Physical Security Monitoring |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.5 | Annex A 11.1.4 | Protecting Against Physical and Environmental Threats |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.6 | Annex A 11.1.5 | Working In Secure Areas |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.7 | Annex A 11.2.9 | Clear Desk and Clear Screen |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.8 | Annex A 11.2.1 | Equipment Siting and Protection |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.9 | Annex A 11.2.6 | Security of Assets Off-Premises |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.10 |
Annex A 8.3.1 Annex A 8.3.2 Annex A 8.3.3 Annex A 11.2.5 |
Storage Media |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.11 | Annex A 11.2.2 | Supporting Utilities |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.12 | Annex A 11.2.3 | Cabling Security |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.13 | Annex A 11.2.4 | Equipment Maintenance |
| Physical Controls | Annex A 7.14 | Annex A 11.2.7 | Secure Disposal or Re-Use of Equipment |
| Annex A Control Type | ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A Identifier | ISO/IEC 27001:2013 Annex A Identifier | Annex A Name |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.1 |
Annex A 6.2.1 Annex A 11.2.8 |
User Endpoint Devices |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.2 | Annex A 9.2.3 | Privileged Access Rights |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.3 | Annex A 9.4.1 | Information Access Restriction |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.4 | Annex A 9.4.5 | Access to Source Code |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.5 | Annex A 9.4.2 | Secure Authentication |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.6 | Annex A 12.1.3 | Capacity Management |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.7 | Annex A 12.2.1 | Protection Against Malware |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.8 |
Annex A 12.6.1 Annex A 18.2.3 |
Management of Technical Vulnerabilities |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.9 | NEW | Configuration Management |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.10 | NEW | Information Deletion |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.11 | NEW | Data Masking |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.12 | NEW | Data Leakage Prevention |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.13 | Annex A 12.3.1 | Information Backup |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.14 | Annex A 17.2.1 | Redundancy of Information Processing Facilities |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.15 |
Annex A 12.4.1 Annex A 12.4.2 Annex A 12.4.3 |
Logging |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.16 | NEW | Monitoring Activities |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.17 | Annex A 12.4.4 | Clock Synchronization |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.18 | Annex A 9.4.4 | Use of Privileged Utility ProgramsAccess Rights |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.19 |
Annex A 12.5.1 Annex A 12.6.2 |
Installation of Software on Operational Systems |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.20 | Annex A 13.1.1 | Networks Security |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.21 | Annex A 13.1.2 | Security of Network Services |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.22 | Annex A 13.1.3 | Segregation of Networks |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.23 | NEW | Web filtering |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.24 |
Annex A 10.1.1 Annex A 10.1.2 |
Use of Cryptography |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.25 | Annex A 14.2.1 | Secure Development Life Cycle |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.26 |
Annex A 14.1.2 Annex A 14.1.3 |
Application Security Requirements |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.27 | Annex A 14.2.5 | Secure System Architecture and Engineering PrinciplesLearning From Information Security Incidents |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.28 | NEW | Secure Coding |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.29 |
Annex A 14.2.8 Annex A 14.2.9 |
Security Testing in Development and Acceptance |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.30 | Annex A 14.2.7 | Outsourced Development |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.31 |
Annex A 12.1.4 Annex A 14.2.6 |
Separation of Development, Test and Production Environments |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.32 |
Annex A 12.1.2 Annex A 14.2.2 Annex A 14.2.3 Annex A 14.2.4 |
Change Management |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.33 | Annex A 14.3.1 | Test Information |
| Technological Controls | Annex A 8.34 | Annex A 12.7.1 | Protection of Information Systems During Audit Testing |
Who Has Ownership of Annex A 5.3?
Several individuals are responsible for the segregation of duties in ISO 27001, beginning with a senior management team member. This individual is responsible for ensuring that the initial risk assessment has taken place.
As a result, other groups of qualified employees should be assigned processes that apply to different parts of the organisation. Order to prevent rogue employees from undermining company security is usually done by assigning tasks to other work units and departmentalising IT-related operations and maintenance activities.
The separation of duties cannot be established correctly without an effective risk management strategy, an appropriate control environment, and an appropriate IT audit programme.
[case_study_slider ids=”88859,101932,92016″ autoplay=”true” autoplay_speed=”5000″]
Use ISMS.online to Your Advantage
ISO 27001:2022 only requires you to update your ISMS processes to reflect the improved Annex A controls, and if your team can’t manage this, ISMS.online can.
In addition to DPIA and other related personal data assessments, like LIAs, ISMS.online provides simple, practical frameworks and templates for information security.
With ISMS.online, you can document information security management system procedures and checklists to ensure compliance with ISO 27001, automating the implementation process.
ISMS.online lets you:
- Create an ISMS that is compatible with ISO 27001 standards.
- Perform tasks and submit proof indicating they have met the standard’s requirements.
- Allocate tasks and track progress toward compliance with the law.
- Get access to a specialised team of advisors to assist you throughout your path towards compliance.
By using our cloud-based platform, you can centrally manage checklists, interact with colleagues, and use a comprehensive set of tools to help your organisation create and maintain an ISMS.
Get in touch today to book a demo.
